HR In Five

The daily five-minute brief on the business of HR.

Daily brief · 5 min
0:00 / 5:39

The day's stories

01

Gartner: over-aggressive AI cuts now forcing costly rehires

A new Gartner report says employers that trimmed headcount too deeply for AI are paying to rehire — a caution for automation-based workforce plans.

A new Gartner report identifies over-aggressive AI-driven headcount cuts as the "greatest mistake" employers are making in the AI era, according to HRD Canada and Computerworld. Per the report, companies that cut too deeply are now incurring the cost of rehiring for roles automation did not fully absorb. The finding raises questions for workforce plans that assume near-term productivity gains from AI, per the coverage.

02

California bill would ban emotion-reading AI at work

California lawmakers passed a bill barring employers from using AI to track employee emotions or neural data — a compliance check other states may replicate.

Full story

California has passed a bill that would bar employers from using AI tools to track employee emotions or neural data at work, HR Executive reports. The measure still requires the governor's signature to become law. If signed, HR Executive says employers would need to inventory any workplace AI that infers emotion or reads neural data — a review that HR teams elsewhere may face if the bill becomes a template for other states.

03

EEOC seeks court help in San Francisco DEI probe

The EEOC asked a judge to assist its investigation of San Francisco's mandatory DEI seminars — a test of workplace trainings against Title VII.

Full story

The EEOC has asked a judge to assist its investigation into DEI trainings run by the City and County of San Francisco, HR Dive reports. According to the agency, the city allegedly required attendance at a seminar series that included "derogatory and vitriolic statements" about White people and White women. The allegations are unproven. Per HR Dive, the request signals federal enforcement is now testing mandatory workplace trainings against Title VII, a case employers running similar programs may want to track.

04

UK right-to-work checks extend to contractors from October

From October, UK right-to-work checks will cover agency workers, contractors and other non-employees — leaving HR weeks to widen compliance.

Full story

From October, UK right-to-work checks will extend beyond the direct employment relationship to agency workers, contractors and other non-employees, Personnel Today reports. According to the outlet, HR teams have a matter of weeks to widen compliance processes that currently cover direct hires only.

Also moving today

  • Women account for 98% of August job gains as male employment falls: US Bureau of Labor Statistics The Post MillennialThe Daily Wire
  • Red Rock Casino ordered to bargain with Culinary Union as stay request fails yogonet.com
  • Channel 4 to cut 340 jobs in restructuring drive Personnel Today
  • Williams-Sonoma to spread tariff refunds to vendors, employees HR Dive
  • Job-switchers are earning more in Canada, U.S.: report HRD Canada
Read the transcript
Welcome in, today is Friday, September eleventh, and we begin with a Gartner forecast, carried by HRD Canada and Computerworld, that nearly a third of AI-driven job cuts will have to be reversed. Thirty percent of positions eliminated in AI-related layoffs will need to be refilled by twenty twenty-nine, often at significantly higher cost, according to a Gartner forecast reported by HRD Canada and Computerworld. Gartner's Tori Paulman told Computerworld the figure is an average across organizations and that the enterprise rate runs closer to forty percent. The forecast argues these cuts deplete talent pipelines and erode institutional knowledge, and it lands as AI has become the leading cited reason for US job cuts, named in more than one hundred sixteen thousand announcements since January, per Challenger, Gray and Christmas data in the HRD Canada account. The same reporting adds a second projection: by twenty twenty-seven, three quarters of organizations that book AI gains as cost savings will be eclipsed by rivals reinvesting them in upskilling. Other analysts quoted by Computerworld questioned the methodology behind the thirty percent figure while agreeing the cuts ran too deep, and some in the trade reframe the story as a loss of institutional judgment rather than a headcount error. Either way, it reads straight through to any workforce plan built on automation savings. Also today, California has passed a bill barring employers from using AI to track employee emotions or neural data at work, HR Executive reports. If it becomes law, employers in the state would need to inventory any workplace AI that infers emotion or reads neural data, and per that outlet's read, HR teams in other states may face the same check if the measure becomes a template. Reaction among workplace-tech commenters leans toward calling the bill narrow, since keystroke logging, camera monitoring and sentiment analysis of internal messaging would remain permitted, and a few note the per-violation penalty is modest relative to enterprise budgets. Separately, the EEOC has asked a federal judge in the Northern District of California to enforce an administrative subpoena in its investigation of DEI training mandated by the City and County of San Francisco, HR Dive reports. The September third filing alleges the city delayed and hampered a probe into a former Department of Public Health employee's race and sex discrimination charge. That employee says she was directed to attend sixteen four-hour anti-racism seminars run by an outside contractor, and the agency alleges the instructor made repeated derogatory statements about White people and White women. Per that filing, the city still had not produced the curriculum, an attendee database, or records of investigations into the instructor by mid-August. The city attorney's office says it plans to oppose the motion. It follows similar EEOC subpoena actions involving Nike and Northwestern Mutual, and practitioner reaction leans toward a compliance point rather than the politics: training content, including vendor material, is treated as discoverable, so review and retain it before purchase. In the UK, right-to-work checks extend beyond the direct employment relationship from October to cover agency workers, contractors and other non-employees, according to a Personnel Today guide for HR teams. That read leaves employers whose checking processes stop at payroll a matter of weeks to widen them. Practitioner commentary, though thin, tends to broaden the frame: some flag that the October change arrives alongside adjustments to how digital verification services are used and how employers confirm the person who turns up is the one actually checked, which would make the lift procedural as well as scope-based. Now, a few more headlines moving the trade today. Following our earlier report on expectations for the August payrolls, the Bureau of Labor Statistics data came in at one hundred sixty-two thousand jobs added, with women accounting for roughly ninety-eight percent of the gain and unemployment holding at four point one percent, per The Post Millennial and The Daily Wire. Red Rock Casino must recognize and bargain with the Culinary Union after Chief Justice John Roberts denied its request to stay an NLRB order while its appeal continues, Yogonet reports. Channel Four is expected to announce around three hundred job losses today in a cost-cutting restructure, per Personnel Today, whose headline puts the figure at three hundred forty. Williams-Sonoma is directing ten million dollars toward the retirement accounts of workers who helped it navigate tariffs and reimbursing vendors for earlier discounts, HR Dive reports. And finally, job-switchers in Canada and the US are out-earning those who stay, according to a report covered by HRD Canada, where one expert says job-changers are highly sensitive to real-time economic conditions.